Poll

What was your favorite Breakfast Cereal as a child?

View Results

Whiskey Book

First Draft - Research
100% complete

Second Draft
102% complete

Third Draft
99% complete

About Organic labels...

04/11/07 @ 05:32:34 am, by Kate Hopkins Email 1267 views • Categories: Organics

As I drive into work, I pass several billboards, each extolling the virtues of whatever mediocre product that happens to be plastered to the board. Normally I think of these ads as visual white noise, rarely getting my attention. And if they do, I rarely think of them past the time it takes for my Mini to drive on by.

But this morning changed there was a change in my routine a bit, as I noticed a sign selling Organic Beer (warning: Flash load).

Upon reading that, my initial thought was that I didn't realize that there was a market demand for organic beer. My second thought was that I hadn't realized how pervasive the label "organic" had become. I knew it had become the new marketing tool for food producers, but it still made some sort of sense to see it on boxes of Kellogg's Rice Krispies or bottles Heinz Ketchup. But beer? Do we need to see it on beer?

I'm not so crass as to believe that the folks a Henry Weinhard's don't have their heart in the right place. For all I know, they're fully committed to creating a sustainable product that doesn't use pesticides and is earth friendly and all of the other buzz phrases that are typically associated with the "organic" term. But I wonder if putting it on as many products as possible dilutes the core principles of the organic movement. Not in the same way that industrial organic has diluted the term, but in a way that makes the word become visual white noise.

As way of a thought experiment, let me list a handful of products:

Some of you may think that there's nothing wrong with any of these products, and you would probably be right. But I'm guessing there's a handful of you who read the list and said "What the heck?? Organic Lipstick and Organic Vodka?" My question is to those of you who fit the latter category:

Does seeing the "Organic" label placed on every product diminish its value on items where it means something? Does seeing the "Organic" label on Vodka make the organic label on tomatoes seem less important?

In my opinion, it does. The saturation of the organic label is starting to make me tune the word out when I view it on labels.

I don't believe this to be the fault of food manufacturers, who mostly have the right idea. I think it's simply a result of an overexposure to the word, so much so that it loses it's meaning.


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: green LA girl [Visitor] Email · http://greenlagirl.com
I think the main difference for me is how processed the food is, and how many ingredients it contains. Organic vodka doesn't bother me at all, really. I have some, and it contains just 2 ingredients: water and organic grain neutral spirits.

The stuff that bugs me is the super-processed food -- coke, for ex, or oreos -- and their potential for pursuing organic labels too....
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 10:06
Comment from: Chuck [Visitor] Email
I don't think widespread use diminishes it's value at all. The USDA did that itself. But, to quit being snarky, I don't think I could ever tell any difference between organic vodka and regular vodka. It is nice to know, though, that the producer is, hopefully, a somewhat better steward of the environment. That's why I buy organic bananas, even though the thick peel protects what you eat from what they may spray on it.
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 10:10
Comment from: Fen [Visitor] Email
I don't believe that the growing number of organic products diminishes the organic movement. If anything, it emphasizes the fact that consumers are becoming more aware of what they put in (and on) their bodies and demanding products that meet their desires.



PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 10:39
Comment from: steeped [Visitor] Email · http://steepingtime.blogspot.com
I agree, and add to that the fact that organic standards for different products differ greatly as well. What exactly are the standards for organic produce like apples and tomatoes versus the standards for things like lipstick and shampoo?
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 11:26
Comment from: Tara C [Member] Email · http://www.dementedkitty.com
I'm with Fen.
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 12:35
Comment from: Christopher Warden [Visitor] Email · http://www.christopherwarden.typepad.com
I don't think using the word "organic," if used with integrity, can be used too much -- assuming that the manufacturers are using utmost integrity when labeling their products.
The problem comes if the organic label is used and the manufacturer is minimally complying (or, worse, partially/not complying) to the high standards required for use of that label.
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 13:39
Comment from: Suzanne [Visitor] Email
I just came upon this in a Natural Food market last week and they had a variety of "organic" bottles of honey for $12 and up. How can you have honey that is not organic? Who is tracking the bees when they collect pollen and overseeing the operations in the hive? It is just another way for these companies to squeeze the consumer for more money.
PermalinkPermalink 04/11/07 @ 14:00
Comment from: Sara [Visitor] Email · http://www.circumspice.wordpress.com
Organic, as the USDA has it, is not about the process by which a product is made, but rather about the ingredients involved in that process. Am I skeptical about how meaningful this system is? Of course. But I think that given this, organic vodka is just as valid as organic tomatoes. Which is to say, not terribly.
PermalinkPermalink 04/12/07 @ 04:28
Comment from: Ann [Visitor] Email
It's not about market saturation, it's about being stewards of the environment. What reams me is seeing excess plastic encapsulating the organic product, and our culture of wasteful consumerism. We don't NEED our organic produce from Trader Joe's sold in so much plastic, and we should be being local produce from our foodshed anyway.

But organic beer? Hell yes, I don't want the hop fields in the Willamette Valley sprayed with roundup! Every small step forward counts.

Which is why we need to fight to keep organic standards HIGH, and always shoot first to buy local and sustainable.
PermalinkPermalink 04/12/07 @ 08:11
Comment from: ED [Visitor] Email
overuse is oxymoronic when applied to a growing term. The real trouble is with the irony of chemical free - organic and all of the ingredients in shampoo and lipstick. I think this really diminishes the label because it corruppts what is supposed to be a term that defines environmental and social responsibility.
PermalinkPermalink 04/13/07 @ 14:35
Comment from: ___desdemona___ [Visitor] Email
Ok, being german and living in germany I might see things a lot different because our laws are very different (100% juice is really 100% juice. Just juice. No added vitamins or sugar or god knows what else. It can be made from concentrate, but the added water needs to be exactly the same ammount that was taken out of the concentrate. I have some american 100% juice sitting here in my basement that has sugar, water, colorings, vitamins, artificial flavours,... added!)

I think the organic (or in germany: BIO) label is a good thing. I don't like the lipctick prices for the organic lipsticks I've seen here so far (8 Euros and up), but I think the idea is good. Do I really want mineral oil on my skin? No. Why would I want it on my lips then...

I don't think it diminishes the value of the _organic_ label. But as I said, we have different laws and I wouldn't be too happy about coca cola or any other big brand repackaging their products as "organic" without changing their ingredients.

Oh, btw: What's up with cheese that contains 2% milk?! What exactly is in the other 98%?
PermalinkPermalink 04/15/07 @ 12:40
Comment from: Say What? [Visitor]
I can see it becoming overused the same as "cholesteral free." it makes my bp rise when I see "cholesteral free" on frozen vegetables - of course they don't have cholesteral - they are VEGETABLES!

Great I can buy organic mac and cheese - but it is still packaged in all that cardboard and paper so how does it help anything?

And the post about the organic honey, very good point, is there a GPA put on each bee to track its path so you know it is only getting nectar from non-sprayed plants? I don't think so.

When will the madness end??
PermalinkPermalink 04/25/07 @ 10:23

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?