The Accidental Hedonist's Guide to:




My Book



99 Drams of Whiskey:The Accidental Hedonist's Quest for the Perfect Shot and the History of the Drink


Communication

Poll

Would you support a soda tax if the revenue went to improving our health care system?

View Results

-->

The Great Garlic Experiment: a photo essay.

02/11/07, by Kristen Email 4524 views • Categories: Food

This week, I found myself faced with a recipe that called for fifteen intact cloves of peeled garlic. And as I cursed and picked papery skin off fifteen freakin' cloves of garlic, I figured there had to be a better way.

And, seeing as I'm a bit of a geek for life hacks, I couldn't just pick any method of peeling garlic; I had to know the best one.

[More:]

Ideally, I wanted a method that required the absolute least amount of picking, seeing as I always end up with a bamboo torture-sliver of garlic skin right under my fingernail. I started with about three heads of garlic, using mostly the bigger cloves and discarding the smaller ones in towards the center.

bowl o' garlic

After some research, I chose 4 different methods of getting the skins off garlic:

  1. Blanching the garlic in boiling water for one minute.
  2. Shaking the cloves in a sealed plastic container.
  3. Soaking the cloves in tepid water for 30 minutes.
  4. Microwaving the cloves on high for one minute.

Here's what I started with:

our contenders

First, blanching. Simple enough. Boil water. Add cloves. Wait one minute. Remove. Peel.

method 1

method 1 results

So, method 1: not bad. The skins didn't slip off, but they came off with minimal effort.

On to method 2: putting the cloves in a plastic container (I used a 4-cup Glad Ware container), and shake, allowing the friction to remove the skins. I shook the container for at least ten minutes, making a hell of a racket and scaring the bejabbers out of all the family pets. This is what I got:

method 2

method 2

As the garlic knocked around in there, some of the skin did come off, but because the surface of the cloves broke, it became a sticky (and fragrant) mess.

Next up, method 3: a soak in tepid water for 30 minutes. Although I didn't get a photo of this method in action, I think you can all envision garlic cloves floating in a bowl of water. For thirty minutes. Maybe it wouldn't have seemed so long if I was in the middle of prepping for dinner, but I got bored and left to tweeze my eyebrows until the timer went off.

When I got back, all I really had... was wet garlic.

wet garlic

method 3


The skins came off slightly easier than dry garlic. I know I could have kept picking at some of them to get all the skin off, but after waiting 30 minutes in the first place, my patience had worn thin.

Last, method 4: microwaving the cloves for one minute. I know I just finished complaining about the 30 minutes the last method took, but let me still say: when something's in the microwave, one minute can be an uncomfortably long time. The cloves popped — in a most unnervingly manner — and in the last couple seconds, they developed a burnt popcorn smell. When I got them out of the microwave, they were hot — and stayed hot for a good five to ten minutes.

Once they were cool enough to handle, I was delighted to see all the cloves had popped open allowing the clove inside to slip right out.

pop

method 4


Initially, I was thrilled, but then I noticed the microwaved cloves looked to be much more cooked than any of the others. Check it out:

cooked?

Not being a molecular gastronomist, I don't know if I just sacrificed some of the garlic's flavor in favor of the convenience of popping them out of the skins easier. Personally, I tend to doubt it — or at the very least, I think the amount of flavor lost is probably minimal.

So. Let's review.

  1. Blanching the garlic in boiling water for one minute. Good, but not great.
  2. Shaking the cloves in a sealed plastic container. The worst of the lot. Do not attempt.
  3. Soaking the cloves in tepid water for 30 minutes. Time-consuming, and offered minimal improvement.
  4. Microwaving the cloves on high for one minute. The best by far, although theoretically sacrificing some flavor.

Now, what to do with all that garlic? What else? Chicken with 40 cloves of garlic. As always, to hear how this turns out, visit me at gezellig-girl.com.


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: LeisureGuy [Visitor] · http://leisureguy.wordpress.com
You really should try one of these. Put the garlic clove in the little rubber tube, roll it with your had pressing down a little until you hear a crackle of garlic skin (about 5 rolls back and forth), and dump out the peeled clove. Works like a charm. And no, I'm not in that business. :)
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 08:37
Comment from: Rebecca [Visitor] · http://k2p2.net
Thanks! Now I know what to make for dinner. Chicken w/ 40 cloves, here I come.

My recipe is a little different though:

http://k2p2.net/blog1/2006/10/chicken_with_40_cloves_of_garl.html
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 08:41
Comment from: Kristen [Member] Email · http://www.gezellig-girl.com
Oh, shoot. I actually meant to address that in this post; I know there are a couple gadgets to peel garlic, but I didn't want to head out and buy one.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 08:47
Comment from: Marieke [Visitor] · http://www.trifles.nl
Very informative, thanks for all the hard work. I usually cut of the head and tail so to speak and then peel. The rolling method also sounds like worth a try.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 09:37
Comment from: ___desdemona___ [Visitor]
I have a recipe for garlic soup that uses 15 cloves/serving. If you're interested I can post it. (No, it's not horrid, the garlic is cooked whole and pureed later.)
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 11:33
Comment from: Annie [Visitor] · http://www.bonappegeek.com
I've tried everything, including those little rubber peelers, but smashing the clove with a bench scraper works best for me. The garlic bruises slightly but it's nothing serious.

Cook's Illustrated published a tip where you throw the garlic into the bowl of your mixer and run it with the paddle attachment to loosen the skins. Have not tried this, but it sounds fascinating.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 11:50
Comment from: Adam [Visitor]
I'm with Leisureguy. I hate gadgets, but those little rubber tubes rock.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 11:51
Comment from: Evan [Visitor] · http://www.monkeytreats.com
I'm with the rubber tube contingent. My wife brought one to the marriage, and I was highly skeptical, having been burned by silly garlic devices before, and having settled on lightly crushing with the flat of a knife blade.

The thing works fantastically well, though. The first time I tried it it seemed pretty worthless, but that's because I wasn't pressing hard enough. Once you have the (simple) technique down, it takes maybe five rolls to completely remove the skin.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 12:26
Comment from: Pille [Visitor] · http://nami-nami.blogspot.com/
I'm with Annie here - I slightly crush the garlic with the blade of a knife, then top & tail and just pull the peel of easily. Definitely on the no-gadgets whatsoever camp:)
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 12:44
Comment from: Patrick [Visitor]
I agree w/ annie and Pille. Whacking the garlic with the back side of the knife is usually enough for me, but if I have a lot to do, I'll use the microwave. One minute is waaaaaaaay too long though. I'll usually do about five cloves at a time for 10-15 seconds. That's all you need to loosen the skins.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 13:21
Comment from: debi [Visitor] · http://www.dejamosdistracted.blogspot.com
If I'm going to chop or mince the garlic, I usually just smash the clove and the skin comes off pretty easily. That method makes mincing the garlic easier, too.

If I have a lot of cloves to peel, I use method 2. Interestingly enough, it works for me, but I do it slightly differently. It's a method I got from watching Rachel Ray, of all people (just goes to show good ideas can come from the worst places). You use two identical bowls, put the cloves in one of them, invert the other and cover, and shake the two together. Maybe that's what makes the difference, but it works for me every time. You do have to put a little elbow grease into the shaking, though.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 13:23
Comment from: Bobbie [Visitor]
I'm in the rubber tube contingent, too. So simple and so effective. And I don't think it takes as long as 5 rolls, even. And for large numbers of cloves, I might try to adapt the idea and use a similar but larger tool - like maybe a rubber mat or one of those flexible plastic cutting "boards" - so I could do several at a time.

It does depend on the kind of garlic, though -- some garlic just has more or less clingy skins, in my experience. Some skins pop off easily and cleanly, once broken or loosened. Is it a matter of the variety, or the ripeness/age, or what -- does anyone know?
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 14:23
Comment from: Nicholas Caratzas [Visitor]
A local Italian grocery sells garlic, pre-peeled, in medium-sized deli containers at prices below what the supermarket charges for unpeeled heads. There's nothing added; it looks like they do it in-house.

So my hack is to just buy 'em pre-peeled - it's better-quality stuff than what the supermarket sells, too.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 16:17
Comment from: Bean [Visitor]
Just another "me too" with regards to the rubber tube. Ours is actually isn't a tube -- just a square of the rubbery material, but it works WONDERS. Just head and tail the clove, drop in on the mat, fold over, and roll back and forth once or twice. Off comes the skin, clean and neat.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 19:10
Comment from: Adam [Visitor] · http://splittingtheadam.typepad.com
I, too, have been swayed by the rubber tube. Most importantly, you can put up to (at my last test) about four cloves in there, thus making things a bit more efficient on the prep side. By the way, to Bean's comment, I haven't had to head and tail the clove--just drop it in and roll...
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 20:18
Comment from: ben [Visitor] · http://bengarland.com
If you're not in a hurry, the way we used to do it at the asian restaurant where I worked: we soaked the cloves in water in the refrigerator OVERNIGHT. Worked every time.
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 20:38
Comment from: Rickie [Visitor]
You don't even really need the special tube to use the rolling method -- those rubbery jar-opener discs that reproduce in your silverware drawer work perfectly. (What? They reproduce in my silverware drawer!)
PermalinkPermalink 02/11/07 @ 20:45
Comment from: popeyemoon [Visitor]
I just put a clove in my palm put my other plam over it and rub three or four times,Wala!!!
PermalinkPermalink 02/13/07 @ 09:23
Comment from: Sara [Visitor] · http://www.circumspice.wordpress.com
I've always been so skeptical of those rubber tubes - maybe I'll have to invest in one. I always do that smash-with-a-knife trick, which works like a charm, but makes a big sticky mess.
PermalinkPermalink 02/13/07 @ 10:19
Comment from: Vanessa [Visitor] · http://www.vanesscipes.com
I'm a whack-it-with-knifer. This "tube" sounds intriguing and if I have a ton of garlic to skin I will try the micro or the overnight water soak. Nice post!
PermalinkPermalink 02/14/07 @ 06:45
Comment from: niall [Visitor] · http://www.thelifeofaprivatechef.blogspot.com
i really must hand it to you, wonderful execution of recipes. Like i said i cook for a billionaire and have tried a few of your recipes now and he loves them! What i love is that you have clearly tested them and they work and are the best for said dish!So many sites just re hash old useless recipes! I will continue to cook for this billionaire(top ten richest in world)using your recipes under the guise they are mine! Sorry
BTW i have plenty of my own on my site!!
Keep up the excellent work!
PermalinkPermalink 02/15/07 @ 18:15
Comment from: Andrew Galarneau [Visitor] · http://buffalobuffet.wordpress.com
A whack with a knife or a bit of crush with the fingers usually does it. Of course then your fingers may smell like garlic, but not everyone considers this a problem ;)
PermalinkPermalink 02/19/07 @ 16:26
Comment from: Bruce [Visitor]
I used to work in a restaurant and would peel several hundred cloves every couple days. In a professional kitchen, the fastest, simplest way to peel garlic is to drop it in very hot oil (a deep-fryer or heavy pot) for about 30 seconds. I say 'professional kitchen' because at home the chore of heating oil would seem to be more effort than payoff.

Result: Skins crack like your microwave method, and the oil helps peel the garlic... pinching the clove between your thumb and forefinger shoots the clove out of the skin. As long as you don't begin to cook the garlic in the oil, it maintains its raw color and firmness.
PermalinkPermalink 02/19/07 @ 21:34
Comment from: Robert [Visitor] · http://www.goodbyecitylife.blogspot.com
the little silicone/rubber tubes are awesome. I got one from Kitchen Express & my partner and I fight over who gets to use it.
PermalinkPermalink 02/21/07 @ 13:21
Comment from: Mark [Visitor] · http://1950shousewife.blogspot.com
Saveur magazine recently suggested a variation on the "shaking in a plastic box" method: instead of a plastic box, use a metal sided container, i.e. pot w/lid or two equally sized metal bowls, one inverted over the other. I put my cloves into a medium saucepan with the lid on and shook for maybe 20-30 seconds. The cloves came out naked! I think the sides of the container need to be harder than plastic.
PermalinkPermalink 02/22/07 @ 09:13
Comment from: Minerva [Visitor]
I just cut the woody bottom off, then roll the clove between the pams of my hands. The skin comes right off. If you get good at it, you can do a couple at once. Works like a charm.
PermalinkPermalink 02/28/07 @ 16:16
Comment from: Vic [Visitor] · http://livingdoing.org
I bash with the back of a knife, but I am a garlic lover and can see the benefits of another method for lots of cloves.

Warning though, don't ever be tempted to use pre-minced "lazy garlic" in vinegar from a jar. I felt nauseous after I ate the meal, the vinegar and garlic combo was revolting.
PermalinkPermalink 03/01/07 @ 00:23
Comment from: kate [Visitor]
My favorite method remains placing the flat of a kitchen knife on several cloves and pressing down until you feel them give just a little. It cracks the papery skin away from the clove, and you can usually pull it off in one piece. I prefer that to boiling methods, even for a large number of cloves.
PermalinkPermalink 03/08/07 @ 08:15
Comment from: Billie [Visitor] Email
Latex (POWDER FREE) gloves work tremendously well. Put the gloves on and simply rub your hands together applying a little pressure; heck if your hands are large enough you can do it with your fingers in one hand. Three strokes your done. The cleanup is a snap. Take the gloves off and throw them away. No smelly tube or washing the counter of a sticky mess. Cost $1.25 for a box of 50.
PermalinkPermalink 02/05/08 @ 03:38

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?