Poll

What is your favorite type of cookie?

View Results

How to Bake Your Own Vegan Redemption

01/28/07 @ 05:52:20 am, by Kristen Email 4626 views • Categories: Desserts, Cakes, Pastries & Pies

Sometime in early 2001, my husband put down his copy of Peter Singer's Animal Liberation and declared our vegetarianism was not enough — we needed to go vegan.

I was vegetarian when we met, a little over a year earlier, and having finally met someone who could cook, he soon joined me as a fellow vegetarian. Transitioning to veganism seemed a logical (if daunting) next step, and we plunged in.

In brief, our foray into veganism lasted about a year, and to be frank, it pretty much sucked. Part of this was due to circumstance; I was prescribed a drug that left me with no interest in cooking, eating, or even shopping for food. But for the most part, it was because a lot of vegan recipes call for foods I don't find appetizing under the best circumstances. Flax oil, powdered egg substitute, casein-free soy cheese... Nayonnaise? Does anyone eat that if they don't have to?

So, when I saw Strict Vegan Ethics, Frosted With Hedonism among the New York Times top emailed articles this week, I was intrigued. I'd baked a vegan cake once. It was chocolate, with whole wheat flour and Ener-G Egg Replacer powder. We ate it — mostly because it was my husband's birthday cake — but it was less than satisfying.

Below the photo of a hot punk girl offering the camera a cupcake, the article opens:

Isa Chandra Moskowitz, a vegan chef, does not particularly like to talk about tofu. Ditto seitan, tempeh and nutritional yeast.

Wow. If only God had made me a smidge differently, I'm pretty sure I'd be in love right now.

The rest of the piece was a revelation: vegan baking with white flour and no weirdo egg replacements? Could a vegan baked good be, well, good? I had to find out.

[More:]

Using the recipe from the NYTimes article, I set out to make these faux-Hostess Cupcakes. Gathering the ingredients was like a culinary high school reunion for me. "Soy milk! Margarine! My old friends! How've you been?"

Anyway. The batter came together pretty quickly:

vegan cupcake batter

And within an hour, the cupcakes were done.

unadorned cupcake

That was the easy part. Next, I made the filling, poked my finger into every cupcake, and squirted filling into each one.

filled

As you can see, I had an awful lot of filling left over, which raised my suspicions, but not being that keen on filling, I was okay with that. I made the frosting and the royal icing — while fielding at least a dozen are they done yet? interruptions, from husband and child alike.

Finally, they were frosted, piped with a little squiggle, and yes, done.

done

I just love the little squiggle, I have to admit. Here it is again:

squiggly

Before I get to what you're all waiting for — how they tasted — some quick notes on this recipe:

  1. It's time consuming. You're not just making cupcakes + frosting. You're making cupcakes + frosting + filling + royal icing. You're filling, frosting, and decorating. It's a project.
  2. I had a hard time squeezing enough filling into each cake. Some cupcakes had almost no filling at all. Admittedly, I've got hands like a ten-year-old boy, so maybe I should have poked holes with something bigger.
  3. If you're using a plastic storage bag as your pastry bag (as I did), double-bag it — especially when it comes to the stiff royal icing. My (single) bag blew out the side because it was so hard to squeeze out

All of that aside, how were they?

Let me tell you: these cupcakes aren't just huh, vegan, you say? good. These cupcakes are holy shit, you actually made these? good. I don't even like cupcakes, but I ate two of these for dinner — and I'm about to eat a third one now. That's how good they are.

I'm not saying this one cupcake recipe is going to make me consider a return to veganism, but it has — more than a little, I'd say — changed my mind about how purely pleasurable vegan food can be.

As always, for more from me, visit my blog at: http://gezellig-girl.com.


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: leonine19 [Visitor] · http://leonine194.canalblog.com
your cupcakes seems so delicious, miam!
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 07:10
Comment from: Sara [Visitor] · http://www.circumspice.wordpress.com
I had the same reaction to the article. I'm an ex-vegan. I stuck it out for four years, and finally gave it all up because so much of vegan cooking seems to be trying to imitate non-vegan cooking, rather than reveling in vegetable goodness. I'll be buying Vegan With a Vengeance as soon as my paycheck comes in. It's refreshing to find vegans who actually love food like I do. Not that I'm giving up my precious cheese again or anything.

I'll have to try this recipe sometime this week. Your cupcakes look phenomenal.
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 10:37
Comment from: Christine Cassidy [Visitor] · http://christinecassidy.blogspot.com/
I'm vegetarian, vegan is just too much deprivation for me. Cakes are one of those things that don't always come out great without eggs so I figured if she was sure enough to publish this recipe they must be pretty good. I made these last week too and my DH was constantly asking, are they ready yet? Yes, they are a bit of work, I agree. He help me stuff them and we were left with lots of filling too. I used the wooden handle of a cooking spoon to poke the holes in so I wouldn't have a fingernail full of chocolate cake. I didn't have enough confectioners sugar to make the royal icing so we just squeezed on the rest of the filling on top - big, fat curls! Yours look perfect! I think these would be fun to take to party, we have lots of veg & vegan friends who would love these. Pretty good we thought, I'd make them again.
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 11:15
Comment from: Kristen [Member] Email · http://www.gezellig-girl.com
Oh, THAT was the other thing I meant to mention: this recipe uses a ton of confectioners' sugar — I had to run to the store in the middle of making this to buy more. I ended up using over two boxes of sugar.
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 11:32
Comment from: raspil [Visitor] · http://raspil.blogspot.com
to fill a cupcake -- cut a cone out of the top of the cupcake. snip off the tip of the cone. dig some of the cake out of the hole. fill. dig out enough cake and you can get a LOT of filling inside. like the size of a truffle. replace top. frost. hooray for an awesome surprise on the first bite.

i got that brilliant advice from Cheryl at Cupcakeblog.com. filling a cupcake with a pastry bag is impractical plus you don't get enough inside the cupcake, like you mentioned. this method is foolproof and very fast. all my cupcakes are filled this way.
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 19:24
Comment from: kate [Visitor]
I tried a vegan doughnut once. pleh. these actually look good!

-K
PermalinkPermalink 01/28/07 @ 20:42
Comment from: Amy [Visitor]
Your cupcakes look wonderful! I've been wanting to make these cupcakes, but I'm waiting for a "special" occassion, since they do seem a bit time consuming. All the vegan cupcakes I've tried from VCTOTW are delicious!

This cookbook will change your life.

PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 06:49
Comment from: Nicky [Visitor] · http://www.deglazing.com
I was glad to find this article on vegan cupcakes. I haven't had a whole lot of luck with my vegan cookbooks so far, it's nice to see there are some great vegan recipes out there.
PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 07:40
Comment from: Kristen [Member] Email · http://www.gezellig-girl.com
Nicky: I've only referred back to one vegan cookbook since my return to omnivorousness: The Accidental Vegan. Its recipes are straightforward, tasty, and (I admit) lend themselves readily to the addition of animal products.
PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 07:56
Comment from: Vanessa [Visitor] · http://www.vanesscipes.com
Thank you thank you for trying these and posting your results. I've been short of time lately but have been oh so curious to see what result the recipe yields. Guess I (like everyone else is doing now) am going to have to buy the book!
PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 14:33
Comment from: farley [Visitor] · http://www.wineoutlook.com
Wow. I stumbled upon your site, attracted to this pasrticular post due to my 6 month relationship with a vegan. It didn't work, and let's just say the fact that my cooking suffered so did not help. But as everyone else says, these cupcakes look amazing! Mouth watering, makes you want to run to the gas station and buy a package...
PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 22:15
Comment from: poppy [Visitor]
I agree, the cupcakes from the cookbook are phenomenal. However, like you said, the recipes call for a lot of sugar. So what's the point of a vegan cupcake if it's chock-full of sugar? Just thinking out loud here...
PermalinkPermalink 01/29/07 @ 22:37
Comment from: Jackie [Visitor]
Thank you so much for sharing these. I can't emphasize how easy vegan cooking/baking is, and almost everything I've been taught is from Compassionate Cooks. If you don't know who they are, check out their site. Or do yourself a favor and check out their podcast. It will demystify what is clearly still a mystery to so many. Also, the founder/instructor/podcaster is coming out with a baking cookbook this year. Anyway, thanks again, and good luck!
PermalinkPermalink 01/30/07 @ 21:31
Comment from: Scott Hughes [Visitor] · http://veganclub.org
I'm a vegan, and a terrible cook. So, I like to see recipes. I don't mind the food, though. I like a lot what I eat.

Thanks,
Scott Hughes
Vegan Discussion Forums
PermalinkPermalink 02/01/07 @ 19:53
Comment from: Margaret [Visitor]
Dear Kristen, Thanks for posting this delightful review. I look forward to testing this in my vegan kitchen in Denmark. Since I like to keep things simple and super tasty, there are certain elements in the original recipie that are unnecessary to me. I would drop the greasy spray on the paper cupcake liners. It is frivolous and fattening and the paper comes off just fine without. Next, I would drop the filling. It is once again too fattening for my tastebuds. Instead I will fold into the batter chopped, roasted hazelnuts and raisons. Or 2 good spoonfulls of English style bitter orange marmalade and a handfull of chopped 70% bitter dark chocolate. Orange and chocolate are excellent together. As for the icing...well sure if you have time, otherwise just a sprinkle of shredded coconut will do for me.
Next I have a question. Usually it is recommended not to mix a cupcake batter for too long, because otherwise the flour develops gluten thus creating a heavy cupcake. Did you mix the batter for as long as the original recipie recommended? Thanks :) from a fellow cookaholic.
PermalinkPermalink 02/18/07 @ 18:02
Comment from: Katherine [Visitor] Email
I'm vegan and I don't think it's very difficult. That having been said, these are awesome cupcakes that make being vegan easier. I love Miss Moskowitz.
PermalinkPermalink 08/12/07 @ 15:25
Comment from: Cassie [Visitor] Email
Try using stevia instead of sugar. It's a completely natural, healthy, no-calorie sweetner! (It is not bad for you or cancer causing like asparateme and splenda, ect.) Happy vegan cooking! :)
PermalinkPermalink 06/10/08 @ 01:29

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?

AH Food Journals