Poll

What Is your favorite type of Whisky/Whiskey?

View Results

Whiskey Book

First Draft - Research
100% complete

Second Draft
102% complete

Third Draft
99% complete

We get Letters v. 24: Lettuce in a bag

04/25/06 @ 05:30:00 am, by Kate Hopkins Email 1951 views • Categories: We Get Letters, Lettuce

This arrived in my inbox the other morning:

Hi Kate

I have been reading your column for about 2 months and LOVE it. I am learning a ton of really great things. I have been looking on the internet for an answer to the following question - What is it that they do to lettuce before they package it in those bags? You know what I am talking about? The lettuce almost has a scritchy feel to it when I chew it? I am getting to the point that I can hardly stand it.

Thanks in advance . . . . .

Mb in Portland OR

Thanks Mb!

Ah yes, that bastion of "convenience" - prepackaged bagged lettuce. The idea behind bagged lettuce was to keep lettuce longer, as well as to remove that tedious chore of...what was it called? Oh yeah, using a knife to chop the leaves.

But is there a difference between bagged lettuce and the regular heads of lettuce?

A lot of it has to do with how the bagged lettuce is processed. And lo and behold, I found this bit of information from Arizona:

Bulk harvesting of lettuce has become more popular in recent years, because of the popularity of prepackage salads. Specific fields may be grown for bulk harvesting, or in many cases, bulk harvesters will follow the wrapping machines, harvesting heads not suited for field packaging. Bulk harvesters consist of large crews of people who cut heads and place them in large cardboard or plastic bins. Bins of high quality bulked lettuce may be slated for the fast food restaurant industry. However, most are transported to salad plants where they are sorted, washed with a dilute chlorine solution or fumigated with ozone, and then chopped for prepackaged or ready-made salads in sealed plastic bags. This type of processing is known as "value-added" packaging.

The answer to your question is in the above paragraph. What you're tasting is probably chlorine.

Now some raw heads of lettuce are also treated with chlorine (it's used to kill worms that may be on board), but from what I could find in the last hour of research is that it's use is not as prevalent as it is in your pre-packaged lettuce. The amount of chlorine used is said to be over 20 times the levels of chlorine than a swimming pool, but I could not find any documentation to support that claim.

The solution? Wash your lettuce well and dry it with a salad spinner. Of course this runs contrary to what some professionals would like you to believe.

Quick side note discovery: A recent report in Minnesota compared the bacteria count of various forms of lettuce, from pre-packaged to simple heads.

Anderson found bacteria in all the samples of lettuce, even the bagged kind which said the lettuce was "triple washed" and "ready to eat".

"We did not find any E-coli, so that's a good thing," Anderson said.

The lettuce with the lowest bacteria count was the simple, unprocessed head of leaf lettuce.

I love finding out that kind of thing.

Thanks again Mb, I hope this helps!

Technorati Tags: , ,


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: deb [Visitor] · http://thesmitten.ivillage.com
A long, long article in the New York Times magazine a year or two ago (I've searched and searched their achives, still unable to find the link) detailed the life of lettuc greens from field to packages in stores, and it was a scary read. Mostly, it dealt with the "difficulty" of finding a mix of mesclun where one leaf did not rot before the rest. (If anyone finds the URL, I'd love to reread it.)
PermalinkPermalink 04/25/06 @ 07:53
Comment from: Joanne [Visitor] · http://www.ForkandBottle.com
The packaging also has me nervous as they "adjust" the oxygen and carbon dioxide levels to keep the lettuce fresh longer. But that chlorine... oh yum.

Here's a link that might be of interest noting a 2003 study in the British Journal of Nutrition which suggested that MAP (Modified-atmosphere packaging) might actually destroy many of the vital nutrients in the salad.
http://www.theecologist.org/archive_detail.asp?content_id=322
PermalinkPermalink 04/25/06 @ 08:31
Comment from: Sharon [Visitor]
I'm kinda wondering whether the organic bagged lettuce/spinach is similarly processed. If so, can they still call it "organic?"

I love this blog!
PermalinkPermalink 04/25/06 @ 19:59
Comment from: rob [Visitor]
I have to admit, I think everyone has gotten the bagged lettuce phenomenon wrong. I never bought it because it was already chopped, I bought it because it was already washed. The most time consuming part of dealing with lettuce is getting it dry after you've washed it. Eventually I decided I didn't actually trust the bagged lettuce so I bought a salad spinner and left bagged lettuce behind.
PermalinkPermalink 04/27/06 @ 06:48
Comment from: Joe Clark [Visitor] · http://joeclark.org/weblogs/
You haven't shown that chlorine (which would always be manifested in a compound, not as elemental chlorine) is actually present in real-world bagged salads, or that the bacteria the researchers found are actually harmful.

Bagged salads are bad ecologically but excellent for nutrition. The advantages of eating them outweigh any unproven disadvantages of chlorine compounds or bacteria.

And the article the other commenter was talking about was in the New Yorker
PermalinkPermalink 04/27/06 @ 09:32
Comment from: Kate Hopkins [Member] Email · http://www.accidentalhedonist.com
I never said that the bacteria was harmful. The risk of harmful bacteria would be proportional to the amount of bacteria subjected to the lettuce.

As far as not proving that chlorine exists in real world lettuce, the industry admits to using chlorine, so that's not that big of a secret. Even if the compound used would evaporate, it would still leave behind residual trace elements. The greater amount of trace elements left behind, the more it would affect the taste of the lettuce (which is what the question was about).

No where in my post did I say "This is bad". I'll leave that up to you to draw your own conclusions.
PermalinkPermalink 04/27/06 @ 09:43
Comment from: visitor [Visitor]
I've been reading your site for a couple months now and it is very interesting and informative. Usually, I'm a lurker, but as an employee of vegetable grower I feel compelled to make a couple comments on the bagged salad post and it's subsequent comments:

1. Bagged salads ARE washed with a chlorine solution. So are all the belts, knives, etc used in general produce harvesting. If you are a person who likes the taste of your food you will probably notice it.
2. Lettuce grown for bagged salads is not "inferior" in the field - it is actually grown specifically for processing - specific density of the head, etc.
3. Product that ends up in bagged salads is handled more. It is also rinsed more. Take that for what you will.
4. All US produce fields, the wells that water them, and processor's facilities are tested by third party auditors for e. coli and other bacteria. The grocery stores that buy the product require such testing (though not all small grocers will be up to standard). You can usually find something on either the grocer's website or the suppliers about this.
5. Product in bags doesn't really last longer, in general. Once product has been cut from a field it begins to die. Additional cutting in processing plant only further accelerates that. Each company will cool the product and "gas" it. One thing some companies have tested is a bag that contains ethylene "scrubbers" in its makeup, which help slowdown deterioration (think of your broccoli getting stinky). Bags in general modify the atmosphere and help veggies last longer.
6. Product in bags is not healthier. The more processed (cut) a salad, the more nutrients it looses. Considering how few American's actually eat their 5 to 10 a day, I don't think this matters too much. Certain cooking methods also leach more nutrients than others.

If you want to know more about produce visit places like the 5-A-Day website, growers sites (specifically look under their "industry links" for quality), and Dole has a good nutrition newsletter.

Eat your veggies folks!
PermalinkPermalink 04/30/06 @ 17:20
Comment from: MICK THE HUMBLE LETTUCE FARMER [Visitor]
Im a lettuce grower Supermarkets told us they require head lettuce in bags now. We have no choice. It creates extra work in field. But that’s the trend these days, consumer want convenience produce. Ours will be bag straight away and taken in the vac cooler for freshness, no chorine needed farm fresh. MICK SEE YA ALL
PermalinkPermalink 05/27/06 @ 04:11
Comment from: Gina [Visitor] Email
Something in the pre-made salads at convenience stores that are rinsed in the chlorine solution makes me severely ill. I don't know what it could be. I get a rash on my neck/chest area, severe stomache issues that last for about 6 hours...
PermalinkPermalink 02/10/08 @ 07:50
Comment from: Maxie Hodges [Visitor]
My issue with bagged lettuce used in restaurants is that it STINKS! I can't bear the smell of whatever it is on that lettuce and therefore cannot eat it. It seems like more and more restaurants are using it. The bagged lettuce I buy in stores used to have this smell, but most don't have it any more. I'm picky about the brand I buy, though. I've complained to several restaurants locally and (if they are a major chain) on their websites. One chain called me and insisted that their restaurant does NOT use bagged lettuce, however, I cannot eat their salads. Wish I knew what to do!
PermalinkPermalink 05/28/08 @ 10:08

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?

AH Food Journals