Poll

What is your favorite type of cookie?

View Results

How to Lose Weight: “Eat Less and Exercise…?” Wrong.

10/01/05 @ 01:09:30 pm, by Jack Email 2653 views • Categories: Food

(From Jack at www.ForkandBottle.com. This is an article about eating, so hang in there. It is also my take on this whole subject. My opinion on this subject is in constant revision, so please feel free to share yours!)

We’ve all heard the line that in order to lose weight you have to “eat less and exercise more”. Sounds so darn simple. It’s been drummed into our heads, relentlessly. If this is a fact, then how come so few have succeeded?

Perhaps because it’s a lie. A big, humongous lie. Just like the hundreds of diet plans you’ve been told about over the last twenty years that guarantee rapid weight loss. If “eating less and exercising more” was the answer, we wouldn’t have the huge and rapidly growing obesity rates in adults and kids that we do. (The latest rate is one in three of us will have diabetes!)

Let’s break it down into three parts:

1) Not Gaining Weight
This requires you to learn how to Eat Smart. You need to learn what foods are “real foods” and eat those ones, and to cease eating the stupid foods. Nothing with HFCS or PHO (partially hydrogenated oils) are real foods. Highly processed foods are not real foods. You need to eat more slowly, not on the run, so that your food is digested and sends the signal to your brain that You’ve Had Enough to Eat. You also need to prepare meals, not microwave meals. (More on this below.)

2) Losing Weight
This, unlike almost every health and fitness plan will tell you, requires a LOT of exercise. 20 minutes a day? Does nothing. One hour a day of serious exercise? You’ve improved your cardio. Two hours a day, every day? Ah, now weight loss can occur, providing you’re diet isn’t stupid foods and that you’re not following the latest idiotic diet-craze. Of course, who has two hours a day to seriously exercise?

3) Not Regaining Lost Weight
Notice how this is next to impossible? Almost everyone regains the weight. Two reasons: 1) Everyone’s body wants to regain that weight, and 2) Very few change their diet, so they’re still eating the foods that cause weight gain. If you buy most of your food at a Big Chain supermarket (other than Whole Foods), I personally think it’s extremely difficult to not regain the weight. So, all of that time, money and effort (and conversation!) – is wasted.

I read recently that the #1 cause of obesity in America is now beverages with HFCS. Falling to #2 is hydrogenated oils (transfat). Why not just eliminate those two from you diet, permanently? Your favorite foods have these? Find ones that don’t have them – believe it or not, they’re out there, they taste as good or better - you just have to find them.

And please, stop fearing fat and bread. Fear bad fat and bad sweeteners and the latest diet crazes, if you must have something to fear.

Keys to Not Gaining Weight

1. Stop eating food with HFCS and/or PHOs (transfats). This is really hard to do as these two obesity-causing ingredients are in most processed foods. In essence, live without most processed foods.
2. Stop eating fake food – most everything labeled as diet food or diet beverage. They do not satisfy hunger and serve no purpose other than to make the companies that make them wealthy. Find a flavored water rather than drink a Diet Sprite or Coke.
3. Eat your meals more slowly. Yes, this takes practice. Try serving a meal in small courses instead. You’ll find you won’t need the last course. Dessert should be eaten after a rest period to see if you're really still hungry, and should be a ripe piece of local fruit or artisan cheese.
4. Cook when possible. You may have to change your lifestyle so that you have the time to cook. Cooking is not heating pre-cooked, pre-packed foods. Cooking is taking raw ingredients and making a meal. Even a very simple meal, or a salad, is great. The smell of food cooking or being prepared in a house is, well, everything.
5. Use some common sense when it comes to food. Eating more vegetables and more types of vegetables. Have a slow, lengthy meal with family and friends once a week. Eating food is supposed to be pleasurable and a luxury for the senses – too many have forgotten that.
6. Avoid all diet plans, TV talk-show advice, magazine “health” articles, etc. No diet foods like Snackwells, Weight Watchers, or Lean Cuisine. Sherlock Holmes classifies these as red herrings. (I’m not as kind.)
7. No eating at fast food restaurants or big chain restaurants. Even when traveling. Find a deli and get a sandwich (without mayo or other bad ingredients) or a rotisserie chicken (preferably organic). With luck you can find a great cheese and nice loaf of bread.
8. Eat organic foods. Eat whole grains. Eat foods without hormones. Eat natural foods (e.g., butter, not margarine). Your body processes these best.
9. This goes for you kids as well! (Deep down you know that the food that comes with a toy isn’t healthy for your kids!)
10. Be happy with your current weight rather than obsessing miserably about it. (Yes, that’s easy to say, but nevertheless, it’s excellent advice.)

You already know that partially hydrogenated oils are so bad that even our pathetic USDA has forced food manufacturers to label the amount of transfat in their food. But you haven’t read a lot (well, except on this site) about High Fructose Corn Syrup. (HFCS). Here’s a link for you at About.com.


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Cindy [Visitor] · http://cindyskitchen.blogspot.com
Hi,
I've been reading your last entries and found them quite interesting.
I'm a slim person and eat real food and junk one, depending on how I feel at the time and what I wanna eat. My weight's always stable.
Loosing weight is I think quite easy. First people really have to learn how to feed themselves, then it is necessary to exercise, often but not necessarily 2 hours/day.
Now, feeding yourself properly. That's sounds easy and I really appreciated your post on supermarkets food and wholefood. I agree that people shouldn't buy their food in Safeway or other big brancds and should rather shop at Wholefood. However there's a reason that makes lots of people shop at Safeway : the price. It's nice to eat real food, it's really nice to eat fresh food, but not everybody can afford it. That's my point, eating properly is nowaday not a matter of choice for lots of people but a matter of means.
Well, I guess that's my point. Rich people can feed themselves the good way while poors have to shop at supermarkets.
PermalinkPermalink 10/01/05 @ 13:55
Comment from: Beth [Visitor] · http://www.zenfoodism.com/
Great commentary. I lost 12 lbs. this year and have made some major changes in my diet, although I have reverted to some of my less healthy habits. I think that avoiding processed foods really is a big help in not gaining the weight back, along with whole grains.
PermalinkPermalink 10/01/05 @ 16:40
Comment from: Kalyn [Visitor] · http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com
First, let me say that I think everyone must find their own path when it comes to what to eat and not eat. I also agree with you 100% that you must cook your own food at least some of the time to have a healthy diet. Too much of what people eat now is just plain junk. I also agree about the importance of exercise. I personally have lost nearly 40 pounds following my own modified version of the South Beach Diet, and I have never felt better in my life. I'm not a low carb fanatic, but I do avoid sugar, white flour, white rice, potatoes and white flour pasta. I eat lots of lean protein, tons and tons of veggies, and limited amounts of whole grains, low glycemic rice and pasta, dairy products, nuts, and fruit. I have kept the weight off for more than a year now and plan to continue eating this way for the rest of my life. For me the biggest advantage of eating the lower carb, lower glycemic way is that your energy stays constant throughout the entire day. It's kind of addicting really.
PermalinkPermalink 10/01/05 @ 18:05
Comment from: Mark [Visitor]
"Eat less and exercise more" doesn't succeed only when people don't do it -- and they don't do it because it's hard. Calling it a lie implies that if you somehow -- against all odds -- manage to do it, it still won't work. A more reasonable statement would be that "However true, a simple exhortation to eat less and exercise is not effective in getting most people to lose weight in the real world."

“Eat less and exercise more” is not a lie, it's just a restatement of the fact that weight depends on the balance of calorie intake (eating) and calorie expenditure (the portion of which that is under control being exercise).

In the end, most of your Keys are simply tricks that people have used to help them *eat less*, tricks that afficionados of "diet plans, TV talk-show advice, and magazine 'health' articles" have heard many times.
PermalinkPermalink 10/01/05 @ 18:31
Comment from: Raspil [Visitor] · http://raspil.blogspot.com
20 minutes of Pilates a day for three days a week has helped me lose (and keep off) 15 lbs for the last three years. i wouldn't say this if it wasn't true.
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 00:05
Comment from: chzplz [Visitor]
Does anyone know how HFCS / High Fructose Corn Syrup is labelled in Canada? I just checked the dodgiest of items in my pantry and only found it listed in only one, which was imported from the US - Kikkoman teriyaki sauce

Have I been unwittingly making good choices, or do I need to watch for something different up here?
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 09:39
Comment from: The Countess [Visitor] · http://trishwilson.typepad.com/blog
Your post hit home for me. I've become interested in The French Paradox. It sounds very much like what you have talked about. I have a book about it that recommended going for walks in lieu of outright exercise. I've begun walking on the beach again, something I have neglected to do all summer. Walking on the beach or along the shore while listening to my iPod has always been my favorite form of exercise. I don't like working out or jogging at all.

We cook our meals from scratch. Any desserts we eat are desserts I have made from scratch. We have successfully eliminated all junk and processed food from our diets. The interesting thing is that we don't crave that stuff anymore. I have no desire for chips or store-bought cookies. We don't eat fast food. Fast food is another major big problem in America. I don't like the taste of it anymore, and it's hard to digest. We don't drink any soft drinks or prepared juices. I can't even drink soft drinks anymore. They taste too syrupy and unappetizing now. We drink either water or iced tea that I make from Earl Gray tea bags. We also drink my lemonade or limeade when I make it, with fresh lemons and limes. My weight is going down, but it's going down slowly and it's going to stay off.

I guess I've been making good choices, and it's showing. I remember that when I took a twenty-minute or half hour walk every other day that I lost a lot of weight. I'll have to start doing that again, along with the healthy diet.
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 13:28
Comment from: Jack [Member] Email · http://www.ForkandBottle.com
Cindy - Middle and rural American seem to have been overrun with big supermarkets and fast/big restaurant chains. Finding a healthy option can be difficult to near-impossible in some places.
Right now, healthy food costs more - I think it's easily worth the money, as food, in general, is very cheap (IMHO). This will slowly change - the demand for organic produce is exceeding the supply in parts of the country (or so I've read) and this is keeping organic food prices higher than they should be.

Chzplz - I don't believe any place else in the world has the High Fructose Corn Syrup problem that we have in the USA. This is because sugar prices are artifically subsized, making corn syrup a much cheaper sugar. The rest of the world, in general, uses sugar for as their main sweetner - in the USA it's High Fructose Corn Syrup.

In general, I wish I had also mentioned in my posting that "Everyone is different and burns calories at different rates, etc."
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 13:33
Comment from: Jack [Member] Email · http://www.ForkandBottle.com
The Countess - Yes, I too am familiar with The French Paradox. I believe the walking after dinner is simply great thing to do (and wish I did it more myself!). I also think finishing with cheese and wine is far superior to have any kind of dessert, health-wise.

Beverages - Most every beverage you buy in a store is too sweet. I'd pass a law to lower the sweetness of all of these beverages by 10% every six months for, say, 2 years, as a gradual reduction needs to begin right now.
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 13:46
Comment from: Melissa [Visitor]
I think exercise is vital, but I've always been on sports teams with people who are overweight despite the exercise because they eat junk.
PermalinkPermalink 10/02/05 @ 21:40
Comment from: The Countess [Visitor] · http://trishwilson.typepad.com/blog
Jack, we occasionally have cheese and wine after dinner, but the cheeses here aren't the best around. Sometimes we have a cup of coffee after dinner, which is something else I picked up from the book. The book recommended that if you drink coffee you have only a couple of cups in the morning, and not drink it all day long the way Americans tend to do. The Count (my husband) used to drink coffee all day, but he has since stopped. He says he feels better without it.

I like to bake desserts, and they tend to be gourmet. We don't eat them every day, but when we do they are a nice treat. I made creme brulee yesterday, and that was very tasty. My son loves it.

Another thing the book recommended which I've started doing is drinking more water, especially one glass as soon as you get up and one right before you go to bed. It really does make a difference. A lot of the time when you think you're hungry you're really thirsty. I think I may have been more dehydrated than I had originally realized.
PermalinkPermalink 10/03/05 @ 08:37
Comment from: Barbara Fisher [Visitor] · http://www.tigerberries.blogspot.com
The French Paradox interests me, but the book, "French Women Don't Get Fat," bugs the crap out of me, because of the authorial voice, which I find to be condescending and snotty.

But, I can attest to this:

When I stopped drinking soda and eating fast food, I dropped three dress sizes.

When I exercise, I feel better, and look better.

When I eat whole foods (which is most of the time, now) I feel better and my skin and hair are visibly and tactilely healthier.

Drinking more water makes me feel better and look better.

I am sick less often now that I eat better food. My allergies are better, and my gastrointestinal system work better.

I look about the same now that I am forty as I did when I was 26, with the added benefit of feeling generally happier and healthier and less stressed.

I do eat less, and I do exercise more. I also eat -better- foods, and I enjoy them tremendously. I am happier and healthier at this age than I was when I was twenty years ago.
PermalinkPermalink 10/04/05 @ 09:13
Comment from: Mike [Visitor] · http://www.eatlessandexercise.com
Interesting article and some good advice. It seems like the theme here is to eat real foods. Just avoiding soda, fast food, and prepackaged stuff will take you a long way.

I'm wondering how many calories you burn by standing in the kitchen cooking a real meal? Seems like 20-30 minutes of standing and moving around the kitchen ought to count for something!

A relevant website that I found: www.eatlessandexercise.com
PermalinkPermalink 03/31/06 @ 07:31

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?

AH Food Journals