Poll

What is your favorite type of cookie?

View Results

The Issues Around High Fructose Corn Syrup

06/03/05 @ 11:19:45 am, by Kate Hopkins Email 9639 views • Categories: Maize, High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS)

Being that I am now covering maize (hence referred to as corn in this post), I figured it was the prefect time to address certain issues surrounding High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS).

For those of you who need to catch up on your HFCS knowledge, HFCS is a modified form of corn syrup that has an increased level of fructose. Ordinary corn syrup is treated with the enzyme glucose isomerase which converts glucose to fructose . Because fructose is much sweeter than glucose, the overall sweetness of the syrup is increased and it becomes a more useful substitute in food processing for sugar or invert sugar syrups. It has since become a very popular way in which food producers sweeten many, many products. It is used so extensively for three reasons:

  • 1. It's cheap.
  • 2. It's sweeter than plain sugar.
  • 3. In acidic mixtures, such as many soft drinks, sucrose will chemically decompose (hydrolyze) over a period of time. This does not occur with HFCS.

The reason it has gotten so much bad press of late is often twofold -

  • - U.S. consumption of HFCS rose 1,000 percent between 1970 and 1990. Obesity has also increased during that time. Ergo, there is a causality between HFCS and Obesity.
  • - HFCS does not stimulate the release of the appetite-regulating hormone leptin. And that may keep you reaching for more soda or food containing HFCS.

I won't address the first point, because the logic is dubious at best. Exercise has also decreased during that same period of time, so to blame HFCS exclusively is just sloppy logic.

However, there may be something to the second point. From a recent Washington Post article:

Fructose is absorbed differently" than other sugars, says (George A.) Bray (a former director of Louisiana State University's Pennington Biomedical Research Center in Baton Rouge) "It doesn't register in the body metabolically the same way that glucose does."

For example, consumption of glucose kicks off a cascade of biochemical reactions. It increases production of insulin by the pancreas, which enables sugar in the blood to be transported into cells, where it can be used for energy. It increases production of leptin, a hormone that helps regulate appetite and fat storage, and it suppresses production of another hormone made by the stomach, ghrelin, that helps regulate food intake. It has been theorized that when ghrelin levels drop, as they do after eating carbohydrates composed of glucose, hunger declines.

Fructose is a different story. It "appears to behave more like fat with respect to the hormones involved in body weight regulation," explains Peter Havel, associate professor of nutrition at the University of California, Davis. "Fructose doesn't stimulate insulin secretion. It doesn't increase leptin production or suppress production of ghrelin. That suggests that consuming a lot of fructose, like consuming too much fat, could contribute to weight gain." Whether it actually does do this is not known "because the studies have not been conducted," said Havel.

Others disagree with this statement. Curt Mercadante, director of communications of the Corn Refiners Association, Inc recently stated that "... both HFCS and sugar are made up of almost a 50/50 blend of fructose and glucose. Both products are also only 4 calories per gram and about equally as sweet. As such, there is no evidence to suggest the dietary impact of consuming HFCS is any different than the dietary impact of consuming sugar."

But there is a difference between sugar and HFCS. Sugar is a naturally occurring substance. The glucose and fructose that make up sugar are comprised of bonded molecules. HFCS, a man-made product, is comprised unbonded molecules. Stating that HFCS is the same as sugar is the same as saying that cake batter is the same as cake.

Not only this, but as Roger Grace of Metropolitan News has noted, HFCS has been linked to some abnormal heart conditions, could mess up the magnesium balance in the body, and may lead to Irritable Bowel Syndrome. To top this all off, London researcher P.A. Mayes believes that high fructose consumption causes the liver to release an enzyme called PDH that instructs the body to burn sugar instead of fat.

None of these items, if true, are anything to be proud of. But admittedly, more research needs to be done.

Regardless of the issues surrounding HFCS, if you are worried about your weight, you should consider the following:

First and foremost, exercise. Sitting around doing nothing means you burn neither sugar nor fat. This is not an optimal state to be in.

Secondly, restrict sugar intake no matter what kind it is. According to the World Health Organization, no more than 10 percent of your daily calories should come from added sugars. If you're eating a 2,000-calorie diet, then consume no more than 200 calories of added sugar per day—which can work out to a 16.9-ounce soda or three ounces of plain M&Ms. Or consider it this way: A trip to the movies can be devastating to your sugar intake.

HFCS is still rather new to our palate, having only been introduced to us in 1966. We still don't know what, if anything, it does to our bodies long-term. To presume it's the only cause of obesity is folly, to presume it has nothing to do with obesity is simply foolish.


Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Barbara Fisher [Visitor] · http://www.tigerberries.blogspot.com
Catching up here---

I doubt that there is a complete causal link between the rise in consuption of HFCS and obesity, but I suspect that there may be something to the link--if nothing else, because more people drink more soda than before.

However, what I didn't see you mention is just how many non-sweet processed foods the stuff is in. It is in most jarred spaghetti sauces (yet another reason to make your own), salad dressings, marinades and whatnot.

Folks can never drink soda in their lives and yet still consume a fair amount of "hidden" HFCS.
PermalinkPermalink 06/04/05 @ 12:14
Comment from: Diane [Visitor] · http://NEW YORK
RLS Suffers are loving this site...
I will no longer drink rum and coke, but rum and gingerale, AFTER I check the label on that...
Thanks,
Keep up the good work,
Diane
PermalinkPermalink 07/15/05 @ 15:24
Comment from: Eva [Visitor] · http://trueepicure.com/blog
I recently found out that I am allergic to corn, and I have been learning a lot about what contains corn, cornstarch, and corn syrup - nearly everything! Thank you so much for all of your work regarding corn syrup. I am so glad I found your site.
PermalinkPermalink 08/11/05 @ 12:39
Comment from: linda hughes [Visitor] · http://visitor
just another example of corn syrup. coffee mate!!! i have ben having a great deal of trouble losing weight. i drink alot of cofee(decaf)if you read the label on coffee mate you will see it says 0 sugars,ah but continue to read and there it is in the list of ingredients...CORN SYRUP!!!!!!!!!!! so now that i checked into this i truly beleive that that has been a problem with my weight loss.I am 56 do eat a healthy diet and just started the gym..told my trainer about what i learned and she has asked me to bring her copies of your material. i truly beleive i have found the culprit of my weight loss problems. also i might add that in the past i was not a heavy coffee drinker nor did i use coffe mate and i never had such a problem with weight .Anyway these are my thoughts hope they are of use to anyone who uses coffe mate.AND lastly i beleive i formed an addiction of sorts to it as now that i stopped i dont seem to crave coffe as much
PermalinkPermalink 09/07/05 @ 08:32
Comment from: Betty (visitor) [Visitor]
Just want to add another product to the high fructose corn syrup list:

Nyquil cold & cough syrup!!!
PermalinkPermalink 01/08/06 @ 10:54
Comment from: :-) [Visitor] · http://[visitor]
I may be very young. In fact I am only graduating gradue school, but I find this site very informative.I am doinga project about America's addiction to fast food. This site helps me understand more fully, why. I think what attracted me to this topic happened just last summer 2005. My mother made me read an article about HFCS. I just read it over to make her happy at first, but then, I got interested. I was amazed in how it was in almost everything and how it is so easy to get addicted to it.
I found all your information very much accurate and I am happy to see that people are seeing how this is making America the way it is. I also read that America was alredy fat from the Paleolithic era already, but in my opinion, it's just an exuse.
PermalinkPermalink 02/07/06 @ 21:29
Comment from: David Hardingham [Visitor]
there is a direct link as in the 50s the american diet started to change with tv dinner soda and fast food and candy bars however the increase in our weights did not start it mid 1970s the same time High frutose was started to be used and as replacment for sugar and as it became a major part of our diet we became much fater
PermalinkPermalink 03/18/06 @ 13:26
Comment from: Steve Sevek [Visitor] · http://www.cdbaby.com/BobDylan
The thing that gets me is - you don't have a choice -- unless you buy your food in a health food store -- all soda pop, all ketchup, all man-made maple syrup.... etc have HFCS in them -- Why don't manufacturers give us a choice??? Why doesn't Coca Cola, which makes so many different formulas of coke give us a formula without HFCS?? Hey some of us would even be willing to pay more to get it!!!
PermalinkPermalink 03/29/06 @ 12:53
Comment from: Chris Shaver [Visitor] · http://www.bookingwiz.com
Watch your own bodily reactions after eating high fructose corn syrup. You'll note the "addictive" quality without having to conduct any expensive studies. Cravings last an entire day. I've found myself craving sweets over 10 hours after consuming "grape juice" (grape flavored HFCS) for breakfast.
PermalinkPermalink 04/22/06 @ 10:16
Comment from: guest [Visitor]
Very true info. when I found myself getting addicted to any food, I check the label and sure enough it has HFCS. I gained 5 lbs in one week by introducing this into my diet. when I eat a lot if it, my vision gets blurry, I get relaxed- frankly, it gets me high.I am going to stay away from it because I can actually SEE myself getting fatter when I eat the stuff
PermalinkPermalink 05/06/06 @ 20:09
Comment from: Jennifer [Visitor]
HFCS__It is in EVERYTHING!! Read your labels! It is used in breads to increase their shelf lives. I have found only one brand of bread which does not contain HFCS. At 43, I am becoming increasingly aware of what I put in my body. I've come to this conclusion- If God didn't make it, I shouldn't eat it.
PermalinkPermalink 06/02/06 @ 20:36
Comment from: stuart [Visitor] · http://www.myspace.com/loverslanenyc
It's insidious what many food manufacturers are doing to the U.S. public... We're being poisoned
like the cigarette industry has done for years and the FDA does very little about it...
High Fructose is in so many foods and that's why I've started buying as many food items as I can from health food stores or in the all natural items
isles... It's healthier, you'll lose weight and food will taste better... We've become a sweetened nation with sour results of unhealthy overweight obese people... Wake up America, change your lifestyle and your lethargic habits. You'll be happier and healthier...
PermalinkPermalink 08/26/06 @ 20:23
Comment from: Chris [Visitor] · http://nona
Talk to any chemist about HFCS and they will tell you the truth. High Frutose Corn Syrup is not recognized as a sugar by the human body and not broken down and is stored as fat. Many companies are relying on HFCS to sweeten products. So please. Read the label.
PermalinkPermalink 09/03/06 @ 14:15
Comment from: Jeanne [Visitor]
Does corn syrup do the same thing in the body as High Frutose corn syrup? I can not get this answer from any website. I'm 62 years old. When our children were small, the doctor told us to put a little corn syrup in water to encourage the babies to drink more water! TRUTH! Is corn syrup more harmful then sugar? Is organic sugar any different then other sugars on the shelf? Case verses sugar beets? All so confusing.
PermalinkPermalink 01/26/07 @ 11:07
Comment from: Ada H. Manning [Visitor] Email
I have been made miserable with diahrea for the last 10 years and tried everything I could think of to get rid of it. Going to the doctor didn't do much good. I read in one of my brothers medical journals that if people would quit eating HFCS and take Lactic Acid Yeast (an emzyme that is good for the gut) it would stop 80% of the diahrea in the country so I tried it. It has been great if got rid of the diahrea(I hope that word is not mispelled)and have been free from it every since. I can go out and have breakfast etc: that I wouldn't dare do before.
I also found that it was is everything. In white bread, hamburger buns, and any kind of packaged food. It was everywhere, so I had to change my diet some but I don't drink soft drinks and there is still one kind of bread that I can get in my store. It is fiber bread (sugarfree) and sour dough bread some times does not have it. My grocery store does not put any HFCS in any of the products they bake so I can still but a pie or cake without it.
Life is so much better and I tell everyone I see and have thanked my grocery for not using it. There was quite a good article in our daily paper that probable kept them form using it. Thank you so much for have the web sight I just hope onlyone that was going through what I was will read it. It is so important.
Ada H. Manning
PermalinkPermalink 04/03/07 @ 12:37
Comment from: Mel [Visitor]
I think a lot of the material out there on HFCS isn't based on science.

You might be interested to see this article I recently came across from the Houston Chronicle. It is on a study which proves there's no link between corn syrup and appetite.

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/health/4961452.html
PermalinkPermalink 07/16/07 @ 06:01
Comment from: lisa [Visitor] Email
My husband works for CoCa Cola-we dont drink it. Coca cola in uk is sweeted with cane sugar,and in japan stevia (wich is better)i guess Coke would rather give us the crapy stuff to save them money.
PermalinkPermalink 07/30/07 @ 09:20
Comment from: Izabael DaJinn [Visitor] Email · http://izabael.com
I just finished a bottle of Newman’s Own “Lightly Sparkling Blackberry” and on the front of the bottle in big letters says, “NO HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP.”

But it's the #2 ingredient listed on the reverse side!! WTH? Is that even legal? I’m really disappointed in such a bald faced lie right next to Newman’s honest-looking face.

Newman is a scam.
PermalinkPermalink 10/05/07 @ 18:26
Comment from: ellen albrecht [Visitor] Email
i read alot of labels only to discover, my thyroid, which is under control wtih medicine MAY NOT BE THE PROBLEM. THERE ARE 3 DIFFERENT TYPES OF SWEETNIG AGENTS PLUS SUGAR IN MOST PRODUCTS, INCLUDING HEALTH CEREALS. I have gained 18 pounds on a 5'1" body and i found the culprits.hfcs and corn syrup are addictive causing me to need a complete meal arounc 1 am when i never even did that pregnant years ago. we should get on the FDA'S back- they approve all this, YET VITAMINS AND HERBS ARE OUT OF THE QUESTION? WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE? ARE THEY DOING THIS TO AMERICANS ON PURPOSE, THE ALMIGHTY DOLLAR?
PermalinkPermalink 10/08/07 @ 10:30
Comment from: Wally Pike [Visitor] Email · http://www.network-marketers.com
Use Stevia as a sweetener.

Stevia is a South American herb that has been used as a sweetener by the Guarani Indians of Paraguay for hundreds of years. The leaves of this small, green Stevia rebaudiana plant have a delicious and refreshing taste that can be 30 times sweeter than sugar.

Stevia has many excellent properties. The body does not metabolize the sweet glycosides from the stevia leaf or any of its processed forms - so there is no caloric intake. Stevia doesn't adversely affect blood glucose levels and may be used freely by diabetics
PermalinkPermalink 12/02/07 @ 03:39
Comment from: Jan [Visitor] Email
just read an article in First magazine for women about HFCS and it's effect on body weight. I then cleaned out my frig of anything containing HFCS, next is the pantry so far the only thing are the baked beans I just bought, :( on sale. Keeping things with sugar in them and will need to shop at the organic health food store and READ ALL THE LABLES from now on. Good thing is that I'm allergic to most artificle sweetners so I only use sugar or stevia when I remember.

Thanks for the added info and will be doing more research on my own.

I feel I wasted alot of food last night but I need to take a stand for my health.
PermalinkPermalink 05/06/08 @ 08:34
Comment from: Amy [Visitor] Email
If you are interested in more things that contain corn copy and paste this link and read all the way to the bottom.

http://www.asthmaandallergycenter.com/CornSensitivity.shtml
PermalinkPermalink 06/08/08 @ 21:39

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))
What color is a red balloon?

AH Food Journals